Guantanahole
I'm going to write about a topic I haven't visited for some time in the vain hope that it would be corrected, now that we have left the George W. Bush administration in its deserved dustbin of history. (Save, that is, for within the W. Library, which is a central repository for the disastrous idiocy that was that presidency writ large, but I digress.) The detention facility at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, has re-entered the news cycle once again, owing in large part to an organized protest - a hunger strike - undertaken by more than 100 of its inmates. I have a few things to say about this shit hole, and I'll keep it brief.
First: Why the hell is this place still open? I know, I know - Congress demagogue'd the issue of closing it down and bringing some of the still-accused to the U.S. for trial and likely eventual imprisonment. (There's a surprise - they demagogue everything!) The thing is, Obama has options, particularly with regard to those prisoners cleared for release. There are third countries they can most certainly be sent to. Obama is avoiding this option because it will garner criticism, most likely. Not a good reason at all.
Second: The hunger strike is a manufactured crisis, by all appearances. They have generally been presenting it as a difficult situation being handled by the Army as best they can, but the fact is that conditions at the prison turned decidedly worse when the Navy handed over control to the Army early this year. The prisoners were searched, their Korans pored over by investigators, and the prisioners' communal priviliges were taken away. They are now kept in isolation 22 hours a day or so. Here's a possible solution to the hunger strike: rotate the Army unit out and bring back the freaking Navy team that was running it before.
Third: If half of these men have never been charged with anything, have been determined to be of no danger to the U.S., why the hell are they being held ... and while they're being held, why are they being kept in prison-like conditions? Many have been there for 11 years. For chrissake, if they're innocent, build them a freaking house in Guantanamo Bay and let them live like human beings until they are released. What kind of warped sense of justice is at work here?
Finally, if any of these men die while protesting their ill-treatment, it is going to exponentially increase Guantanamo's value as a jihadist recruitment tool. Add that to your security considerations, Barry.
luv u,
jp
P.S. - Happy May Day. Invented in America, celebrated elsewhere. Ask why.
First: Why the hell is this place still open? I know, I know - Congress demagogue'd the issue of closing it down and bringing some of the still-accused to the U.S. for trial and likely eventual imprisonment. (There's a surprise - they demagogue everything!) The thing is, Obama has options, particularly with regard to those prisoners cleared for release. There are third countries they can most certainly be sent to. Obama is avoiding this option because it will garner criticism, most likely. Not a good reason at all. Second: The hunger strike is a manufactured crisis, by all appearances. They have generally been presenting it as a difficult situation being handled by the Army as best they can, but the fact is that conditions at the prison turned decidedly worse when the Navy handed over control to the Army early this year. The prisoners were searched, their Korans pored over by investigators, and the prisioners' communal priviliges were taken away. They are now kept in isolation 22 hours a day or so. Here's a possible solution to the hunger strike: rotate the Army unit out and bring back the freaking Navy team that was running it before.
Third: If half of these men have never been charged with anything, have been determined to be of no danger to the U.S., why the hell are they being held ... and while they're being held, why are they being kept in prison-like conditions? Many have been there for 11 years. For chrissake, if they're innocent, build them a freaking house in Guantanamo Bay and let them live like human beings until they are released. What kind of warped sense of justice is at work here?
Finally, if any of these men die while protesting their ill-treatment, it is going to exponentially increase Guantanamo's value as a jihadist recruitment tool. Add that to your security considerations, Barry.
luv u,
jp
P.S. - Happy May Day. Invented in America, celebrated elsewhere. Ask why.
Comments