Bad guys.
When I watch news reports about the Ukraine crisis, I'm reminded of that Dave Mason song from back in the seventies, that went something like this:
Right, well ... I was never a big fan of Dave's, but you get the idea. Part of the problem with our once-over-lightly media culture is that there is an extraordinarily rapid resort to black-and-white, wrong vs. right narratives that are easy to report, easy to digest, easy to repeat again and again. In all that, we lose the sense that it's possible to have two assholes in a fight - adversaries who are divided by conflicting claims, not by a contrast between absolute good and absolute evil.
I guess what particularly galls me about the current state of play is that when you draw attention to this fact, you are accused of being an apologist for the Putin regime. Fact is, Putin's regime is the model of governance in Russia that the United States clearly preferred, one we actively encouraged and supported relatively uncritically until the falling out around the Iraq war. What we're staring in the face right now is the product of two failed American policies: (1) support for a strong executive in Russia from the Yeltsin years forward, and (2) insistence not only on perpetuation of NATO after the end of the Cold War, but expansion of the alliance deep into eastern Europe, over the vehement objections of the Russians.
Russia's objection to NATO expansion? Well, this is just a guess, but I'm pretty sure they are against any major military alliance on their western flank, probably because they were invaded four times, starting with Napoleon, the last time nearly destroying Russian society. That's a living memory for some in Russia, and something no doubt written in their DNA at this point. You can say they're a little sensitive about threats from their west. Just a little.
That doesn't excuse beastly behavior, but you have to admit ... compared to the suppression of Hungary or Czechoslovakia, this invasion and annexation of Crimea has been pretty tame. I'm just saying, we need to dial it back a little, and remember that we still have thousands of nuclear weapons. Indeed, there can be no military conflict between Russia and the United States that won't practically guarantee the destruction of all of humankind.
If we fight, no one wins. Take that to the bank.
luv u,
jp
So let's leave it alone
Because we can't see eye to eye
There ain't no good guys
There ain't no bad guys
There's only you and me and
We just disagree
Right, well ... I was never a big fan of Dave's, but you get the idea. Part of the problem with our once-over-lightly media culture is that there is an extraordinarily rapid resort to black-and-white, wrong vs. right narratives that are easy to report, easy to digest, easy to repeat again and again. In all that, we lose the sense that it's possible to have two assholes in a fight - adversaries who are divided by conflicting claims, not by a contrast between absolute good and absolute evil.
I guess what particularly galls me about the current state of play is that when you draw attention to this fact, you are accused of being an apologist for the Putin regime. Fact is, Putin's regime is the model of governance in Russia that the United States clearly preferred, one we actively encouraged and supported relatively uncritically until the falling out around the Iraq war. What we're staring in the face right now is the product of two failed American policies: (1) support for a strong executive in Russia from the Yeltsin years forward, and (2) insistence not only on perpetuation of NATO after the end of the Cold War, but expansion of the alliance deep into eastern Europe, over the vehement objections of the Russians.
Russia's objection to NATO expansion? Well, this is just a guess, but I'm pretty sure they are against any major military alliance on their western flank, probably because they were invaded four times, starting with Napoleon, the last time nearly destroying Russian society. That's a living memory for some in Russia, and something no doubt written in their DNA at this point. You can say they're a little sensitive about threats from their west. Just a little.
That doesn't excuse beastly behavior, but you have to admit ... compared to the suppression of Hungary or Czechoslovakia, this invasion and annexation of Crimea has been pretty tame. I'm just saying, we need to dial it back a little, and remember that we still have thousands of nuclear weapons. Indeed, there can be no military conflict between Russia and the United States that won't practically guarantee the destruction of all of humankind.
If we fight, no one wins. Take that to the bank.
luv u,
jp
Comments